Do you want a partner in theory, but find the actual process of dating to be absolutely unappealing? Have you ever said something along the lines of, “I just want to be set up. I don't want to go through the whole online dating process”? Do you find yourself fantasizing about being in a relationship, while also having no interest in putting yourself in situations where you might actually meet someone?
If so, congratulations! You might be the owner of some real fear and anxiety around dating. (I say this with love.)
Now, to be clear, there is nothing wrong with not loving the idea of dating apps. There are plenty of cons to modern dating. It can be exhausting, it can feel shallow and looks-based, and it can be impersonal. However… I think it's worth exploring when our dislike of dating starts to look a little more like avoidance. If finding love is a goal of yours, but you can’t bring yourself to actually take the steps to get there, read on.
Dating: The Fantasy vs. The Reality
Something I hear often from my single clients are their fantasies around dating, and what they have grown to believe a relationship “ought to” look like. In general, I think we have built up too much pressure and expectation around romantic relationships. We expect them to meet our every need: Physically, emotionally, sexually, and so on.
We may visualize this perfect partner who we can talk all night with, make every meal with, and travel with. We would also have an exciting and fulfilling sex life with them, and they would be the perfect parent, as well as a pseudo-therapist. And they would all be wrapped into one perfectly attractive package. We all yearn for the comfort of being loved unconditionally by the person who will also meet every one of our needs. And you know what? These are all beautiful goals for a relationship.
But when someone suggests downloading a dating app, we hit a wall. How likely is it that this absolutely perfect person is waiting to meet us on Hinge, or Bumble, or Tinder? On what planet is the partner of our dreams simply a few swipes away? And even if they were on the apps, wouldn’t that be a red flag?
We're experiencing a level of resistance suited for an impossible situation. We have these ideas of what we would settle for, and to be honest…We’re not sure they’re even attainable, or in some cases, deserved. And even if so, we would want our story to be more unique, and exciting, than the standard “we met on the apps” we hear all the time.
Now, all of this, again, is not to encourage everyone to use the apps. I see this resistance off of the apps, too. When I say, “Go to a singles event, or bring your business card to pass out to people you find cute next time you go out!” I don’t often get a look of joy and excitement. Actually, more often than not, what I hear nowadays is “I just want a friend to set me up with someone they’ve already vetted”.
We all want the outcome, but we're not particularly excited about the process. Actually, we’re downright resistant to it. And while some of that resistance might be a completely logical response to the current dating landscape, sometimes it is worth asking ourselves what we're actually avoiding.
Dating Requires Vulnerability
When you decide to start dating, you’re signing up for situations where you’re actively meant to judge one another. Not only do you have to vet someone to see if they could be good for you, but you’re also opening up the floor for them to vet you, too. You're opening up to someone who may not be there tomorrow. You're expressing interest without knowing whether that interest will be reciprocated or scoffed at. And scariest of all, you're allowing yourself to get excited about someone who might ultimately decide they aren't excited about you.
For those who struggle with rejection, self-esteem, trust, or feeling uncomfortable being emotionally vulnerable, dating can bring up a paralyzing level of anxiety. If you've spent a significant amount of time protecting yourself from rejection, disappointment, or pain, it makes sense that putting yourself in a position to experience those things again doesn't sound particularly appealing.
The problem is, avoiding dating doesn't necessarily make those fears go away. It just means we don't have to encounter them, and in doing so, neglecting something that we might really crave deep down.
The Appeal of Being Set Up
Wouldn't it be lovely if someone who knows you, loves you, and has your best interests at heart could just hand you your future partner? No months, or years, of searching. No awkward introductions, no dating app conversations that go absolutely nowhere, just a perfect partner plopped directly into your lap by someone you trust.
Yes, it sounds fantastic. And yes, it could happen! But I believe that wanting to be set up as your main form of searching is often our protection against the discomfort of vulnerability, the possibility of being rejected, and the effort of dating.
If you’re in that group, let me ask you this: Are you genuinely open to meeting someone, or are you only open to meeting someone who will already be perfect for you?
Here's the thing: Even if someone hands you your dream partner on a silver platter, you're still going to have to date them. You'll still have to navigate the uncertainty, communicate your feelings, express interest, tolerate vulnerability, and figure out whether you're compatible. You might be able to skip the search, but you can’t skip the stages of building a relationship.
Do you have high standards, or are you avoiding dating?
For many, anxiety around dating isn’t especially clear to us. Instead of looking like fear or stress, I often see unrealistic expectations that lead into an endless list of reasons why we aren’t looking for the partnership we so desperately crave.
We might say we “got the ick” from someone after one slightly awkward interaction, which gives us the opportunity to decide we're not interested… before giving ourselves the opportunity to develop interest. We might convince ourselves that nobody is compatible with us, because finding someone who feels like a perfect fit is a lot less scary than navigating the uncertainty of getting to know an imperfect human being.
So, what do we do about it?
First, get a little more curious about your resistance to dating. Do you know where your anxiety lies, and why? Or have you been denying yourself the experience for reasons completely foreign to you? Instead of immediately concluding that dating is terrible and you want no part of it, try asking yourself what specifically feels so uncomfortable. Is it the rejection, the confidence, the attachment? Is it the standards you set for yourself due to seeing relationships that went poorly early on? Do you struggle to see yourself as being desirable, or deserving of a healthy partnership? Once you start to consider these things, talking about them in therapy is a wonderful next step.
This is also a call to sit with discomfort more often in your daily life. If you want a partner, but you don’t want to date, try talking to strangers in a platonic setting first. See how manageable it is to interact with someone who you have no intention of seeing romantically. If you can tolerate that, you might be ready to try your hand at dating. The goal isn't to force yourself into dating situations that make you uncomfortable, rather, it's to understand whether your choices are being guided by what you genuinely want or by what you're afraid might happen.
You don't need to become a pro app-user, or someone who gleefully approaches strangers at bars, or who goes on three first dates a week. You can start as small as you need. Whether that’s talking about dating more in therapy or with friends, or actually expressing interest in someone, all steps forward are progress. Practice allowing yourself to be uncomfortable and eventually, the things that were once hidden by our defense mechanisms will reveal themselves to us, so we can push through them to get what we want from our life.

